FBOY Island finale spoilers: Who did the women pick? Who is still together?

The FBOY Island finale is now streaming on HBO Max! Who did Sarah, Nakia, and CJ pick? We’ve got all the details and a shocking (but not really so shocking) outcome.

Please note spoilers are ahead if you are not caught up! 

How did you enjoy the first season of FBOY Island? Did it deliver the messy drama you were craving from reality TV? For me, it checked all the boxes! If you enjoy shows like Love is Blind and The Bachelorette, you’ll hit the reality TV jackpot with FBOY Island. 

Once again, please note there are spoilers ahead! Watch the finale before reading on.

Who did CJ pick on FBOY Island?

CJ picked Jarred Evans, aka “New Jared” aka a Nice Guy. And CJ is the only one who picked a Nice Guy. CJ split the $100k with Jarred and decided to continue their relationship.

Are CJ and Jarred still together?

There are no images of CJ and Jarred together on social media, it could be too soon as HBO Max may want the spoilers a secret until the finale has been seen by more people. Casey shares that he is no longer an Fboy (only a little bit), and you know what? We believe him. Good for you Casey!

Who did Nakia pick on FBOY Island?

Nakia picked self-proclaimed Fboy OG Jared Motley. She took her chances even after learning Garrett’s decision (we get to that just below), but OG Jared truly changed for the better. Why? Because OG Jared decided to split the money and continue the relationship!

Are Nakia and OG Jared still together?

Are they still together? We’re not sure! The two could still be keeping their relationship a secret to avoid spoiling anything to those who haven’t watched the finale.

Who did Sarah pick on FBOY Island?

Sarah, you saw and were aware of all the red flags, girl! The heart wants what it wants, I guess!

Despite the major reveals and red flags, Sarah picked Garrett. And Garrett…picked the money! That’s right, just as he told audiences from the very beginning, Garrett is an Fboy and will forever be an Fboy.

I was surprised by how unapologetic Garrett was, though. I never trusted him, but he was pretty cold-blooded and said he doesn’t see a relationship with Sarah at all.

In the end, host Nikki Glaser told Garrett and the others that Fboys shouldn’t get the money, so it will be going to a charity of Sarah’s choice, instead.

If you ask me, this isn’t fair. That was the whole point of the game and Sarah made her choice. Garrett won the money fair and square, did he not? Nikki warned them. She clearly stated that if they pick an Fboy, the Fboy decides to split it or run. Garrett should have kept the money and taught everyone a valuable lesson.

Josh was super nice, a real gentleman, and wonderful from the beginning. It’s a shame Sarah couldn’t see what was right in front of her. At least Sarah learned a thing or two from this.

What did you think about that twist with the prize money? Did the women make the right choice?

All episodes of FBOY Island are streaming on HBO Max.