Who is the Banana Split on The Masked Singer?

UPDATE: The Banana Split was revealed to be David Foster and Katharine McPhee. 

Another double mystery on The Masked Singer continues to leave us scratching our heads — who is the Banana Split? Let’s put our heads together and gather up all clues to try and solve this.

Spoilers ahead if you are not caught up on all the episodes!

This season, we have seen two masked contestants participating together: The Beach Ball and the Banana Split. And after the Beach Ball turned out to be Honey Boo Boo and Mama June, we are ready for anything! No, seriously, I did not see that coming at all so let’s just all expect the unexpected.

Who is the Banana Split on The Masked Singer? All the clues

Other double mysteries from previous seasons have included Clint Black and Lisa Hartman (season 4) and the Hanson brothers (season 5). So who is the duo behind the Banana Split?

The Banana Split first appeared on Sept. 29, with clues that we weren’t able to break down. But now that we have more, we can try to guess.

• We know the ice cream part of the Banana Split is a female
• The ice cream sang while the Banana (a male, we assume) played the piano
• Money guns
• Champagne and outdoor dining
• A silver medal
• They also once displayed a set of three red dice, each with a 2
• A rabbit
• Recipe cookbook
• A First Aid Kit
• The line “the last time we worked together, it was a nightmare”
• Flowers

The Banana Split on The Masked Singer could very well be: David Foster and Katharine McPhee.

Other guesses: John Legend and Chrissy Teigen, Stephen and Ayesha Curry (can Stephen play the piano?), and Distractify has an interesting guess in bro and sis duo Derek and Julianna Hough.

What time is The Masked Singer season 6 episode 9 on tonight?

The episode is titled “Group B Semi-Final” and it airs on FOX at 8 p.m. ET. The episode is scheduled to run 1 hour, so stay tuned 8-9 p.m. ET so you don’t miss a thing. Do you think the Banana Split will be unmasked tonight?