Temptation Island: Five Winners of the first season

Evan is obviously a winner.

If it weren’t already obvious, Evan made an upgrade with his move to Morgan Lolar. Without degrading either woman, Morgan is mentally, psychologically, and physically more attractive than Kaci.

Additionally, he was pressured for nearly a decade and stuck by Kaci’s side. She pushed and pushed, likely making him more insecure. More traumatized. Kick a dog long enough and the dog is going to bite back. It should say quite a bit that Evan proposed to Morgan roughly six months after leaving the show.

On top of that, for the amount of time Evan and Kaci were together, she no doubt knew about his father’s murder. “Marriage or else”-ultimatums were guaranteed to trigger Evan’s insecurities. Forcing him on Temptation Island likely sparked the flames of relationship doubt.

Morgan is a winner.

By virtue of the relationship and marriage proposal from Evan, there is no doubt Morgan is a winner. She went onto Temptation Island looking for not just a fling, but marriage. She found a man who obviously adores her to no end, and the greater majority of the entire show was a video history of the initial stages of their budding romance. Who wouldn’t love to have that keepsake?