From the very beginning, American Idol hopefuls hoped to hear four words at the end of their auditions: You’re going to Hollywood! The Hollywood round of the competition has always been a favorite among viewers and a pivotal part of the show’s format, as it’s when the hopefuls are put through the toughest tests in the season.
Over the years, we’ve seen changes to the Hollywood Week format, but the heart of the round has always been to help give the contestants the chance to shine as they compete for a place in the Top 24. Hollywood Week has long been a favorite among fans, as it's a time in the season when we become even more invested in the contestants as we hold our breath through each stage of the round, hoping our favorites won’t crack under the pressure and impress the judges enough to earn a place in the Top 24 when America begins voting.
Perhaps that’s why it is so shocking to know that after 24 seasons, American Idol is eliminating Hollywood Week in what will be the biggest formatting change the show has ever seen.
As first announced by Deadline, American Idol is eliminating Hollywood Week from the series in what the show is describing as an effort to get fans to live shows quicker. Rather than contestants hoping to get a ticket to Hollywood during their auditions, they’ll have to hope they did enough during their auditions to be awarded one of 25 Golden Tickets, which will send them right to Hawaii to compete for America’s votes.
So how will this new format work? Well, there will be three audition episodes, and then we’ll go right into the two Hawaii shows before we go to the live shows. Those live shows will no longer be coming to fans live from California but instead will be moving to Trilith Live in Atlanta, Georgia, making yet another major change for the show.
“The auditions and the live shows are the bread and butter for this show, and the process of a Hollywood Week is really a culling process that we were televising. Going to America’s Vote is what this show is about. Hollywood was a metaphor,” showrunner Megan Michaels Wolflick told Deadline.
The show will also give three American Idol hopefuls who fail to earn a Golden Ticket the chance to punch their ticket to Hawaii by performing at the Country Music Awards, with fans voting for who will get the final spot and the results to be announced on Dick Clark’s New Year’s Rockin’ Eve.
It’s certainly a bold change for the format and one that is already dividing fans. As someone who has watched from the very beginning, I can’t help but feel as though this massive change hints that American Idol’s days are becoming limited. In recent years, it’s already become harder to connect with contestants as we spend less time with them on their journeys due to the formatting shifts, including bigger waves of eliminations during the live shows.
Now that we’re eliminating Hollywood Week, we’ll essentially only have two chances to see most of the contestants perform before we go to the live shows, and we won’t get those added episodes of performances that also gave us a chance to become even more invested in their journey by rooting for them during Hollywood Week’s highs and lows. It’s sort of like what we’ve seen occurring on other shows such as America’s Got Talent and The Voice. The shows are eliminating rounds of competition, meaning the contestants are performing for America only a handful of times before a winner is crowned.
Gone are the days when we get to know the contestants over the course of multiple episodes before ever going live and voting for them. Instead, the shift seems to be more toward giving the judges screentime than on investing in the contestants, which explains why the winners of these various reality shows aren’t going on to enjoy successful careers at the same level winners once did at the peaks of these shows.
American Idol has already implemented so many changes over the years, and the elimination of Hollywood Week makes me ready to say goodbye to the show, as it’s clearly no longer the series millions once fell in love with.
