6 Guest stars in Supernatural Season 4 you forgot about

Supernatural Season 4 had plenty of recognizable faces, but what about the guest stars you forgot? Here are the top six.

While there were plenty of recognizable faces in Supernatural Season 4, there are other guest stars that you overlooked. They may have been covered in makeup, making it hard to recognize them, or they had small parts. Another reason is because they weren’t major stars at the time, so you only realize they were in the episodes when you look back!

Here’s a list at all the guest stars you’ve possibly forgotten about over the years. Are you ready?

Dameon Clarke & Joanne Kelly

Dameon and Joanne appeared in the same episode, as husband and wife. You’re going all the way back to Supernatural Season 4, Episode 4 for this. One of the reasons I didn’t recognize them at first is because this isn’t one of my favorite episodes. In fact, it’s one of my least favorites.

Joanne is the one you’re more likely to overlook, as Dameon played Jack Montgomery, the man going through the change. Joanne was his wife, Michelle.

Both had successful careers before Supernatural and have only done one guest spot each on the series (this episode). They’ve gone on to appear in other major shows, with Dameon as Detective Mumford in How to Get Away with Murder and and Joanne as Vanessa Moore in Hostages and Alison Shaw in Zoo.

SUPERNATURAL — “Monster Movie” — Photo: Sergei Bachlakov/The CW — Acquired via CW TV PR /

Todd Stashwick

You’ll be forgiven for not recognizing Too Stashwick at first. After all, he plays one of the most memorable characters of the fourth season. Yes, he’s Dracula in Supernatural Season 4, Episode 5, titled “Monster Movie.”

Some of you have said you skip this episode, but this was the one that helped get my husband into the series. It has a special place in our hearts and I adore that it’s Todd who played such an awesome Dracula.

You’ll recognize Todd for other fantasy shows, including The Originals and Teen Wolf. He’s also been in the likes of CSI: Miami, 12 Monkeys, Justified, and Heroes. Oh, and he did the voice of Mr. Johnson and others in Phineas and Ferb.

Watch your favorite shows on fuboTV: Watch over 67 live sports and entertainment channels with a 7-day FREE trial!

Dylan Minnette

The first time you watched Supernatural Season 4, you wouldn’t have recognized Dylan Minnette. This was around the time he was getting into acting, landing other guest roles on shows, including Grey’s Anatomy.

Now when you watch it, you’ll start to recognize him. He’s changed a lot as he’s grown up, but yes, this is the boy that is now in 13 Reasons Why. Since being the boy who made friends with the children in the walls in one of Supernatural‘s scariest episodes, he’s talked to dead people, got a new set of ears, and suffered a home invasion.

SUPERNATURAL — “Family Remains” — Photo: Michael Courtney/The CW — Acquired via CW TV PR /

Candice King & Marie Avgeropoulos

Like Dylan Minnette’s spot, the first time you watched Supernatural Season 4, you would have possibly overlooked the guest stars. This is especially the case for Marie Avgeropoulos, who wasn’t in much of the episode anyway.

Both have gone on to play lead roles in other CW shows, The Vampire Diaries and The 100. Before they were famous, they took on guest spots in “After School Special.” Candice King (credited as Accola at the time) was the girlfriend of Young Dean, played by Brock Kelly. Marie was Taylor, a girl who ends up becoming one of the victims.

You’ll recognize them with rewatches, but the first time you ever saw the episode (especially if you watched back in the day) you would have forgotten.

Next. 4 guest stars you forgot were in Supernatural Season 3. dark

Who did you forget was in Supernatural Season 4 until rewatches? Who didn’t you recognize under the makeup? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Follow SPN Hunters on Facebook for more Supernatural Season 4 to get you through the winter Hellatus.

Home/Supernatural